Pros & Cons: electric, propane, and diesel Forklifts

The decision to use an electric, LP or diesel forklift is determined by the application, run-time requirements, number of shifts, and environment of your company.  For assistance in making that decision, here are some advantages and disadvantages of each:

Electric Forklift Advantages

  • Zero tailpipe emissions = safer work environment
  • Less noise during operation
  • No outside storage of tanks is necessary
  • No engine, transmission, or radiator = cheaper maintenance
  • Low center of gravity = better capacity and stability ratings
  • Turning radius specs are better which increases storage capacity and reduces potential for damage
  • Rearward visibility increased with no propane cylinder in the way
  • Long major component life
  • Fewer waste fluids
  • Lowest total cost of ownership

Electric Forklift Disadvantages

  • May not perform well when required in high/constant duty or cold/wet applications
  • Cleaning, watering, and charging requirements of the battery may not be efficient in a multi-shift operation
  • Forgetting to charge the battery overnight can result in significant productivity losses the next day
  • Initial investment is higher
  • Adequate ventilation around the lift is required when charging the battery
  • Battery chargers have certain voltage requirements and the existing electrical service must meet those
  • Proper safety equipment like eyewash stations and proper flooring are additional costs to consider

LPG/Propane Forklift Advantages

  • Little risk associated with running out of fuel other than the inconvenience of having to change propane cylinders
  • Initial investment is lower
  • Better than most electric forklifts in high/constant duty applications
  • Suitable for indoor applications except if there are food or beverage requirements

LPG/Propane Forklift Disadvantages

  • Rearward visibility is restricted due to the location of the propane tank
  • Liability exposure in the form of possible leakage of the fuel system.  Operators need to be trained in safe handling of propane fuel.
  • Higher fuel costs
  • Higher chance of injuries due to the weight of the tanks and frequency that they need to be changed
  • Freezing temperatures may cause starting or reliability issues
  • Fossil fuel prices are predicted to increase over the years and not readily available in remote locations

Diesel Forklift Advantages

  • Lower fuel costs
  • Diesel lifts product more drive line torque at low RPM when compared to LPG and electric
  • Rearward visibility is better since there is no propane tank mounted on the back
  • Lower total cost of ownership when compared to LPG
  • Longer engine life than the LPG

Diesel Forklift Disadvantages

  • Not suitable for indoor use without expensive emissions accessories and proper ventilation
  • Initial cost of investment is high
  • Bulk tank for fuel storage is sometimes required and municipal regulations may apply to the tank installation
  • Fossil fuel prices are predicted to increase over the years and not readily available in remote locations

Cost comparisons based on 1,000 hours a year for 5 years

cost-of-ownership